Pilot Whales Maybe Victims of Friendly Fire by The Navy

BY Kirsten Massebeau and Barbara Napoles

Pilot whales are again discovered on the Gulf of Mexico that lies within the Navy’s Atlantic Training Range. NOAA’s update:

“The U.S. Coast Guard continued to search for the stranded pilot whales during the weekend with no luck. Around 1pm Sunday, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service found 11 dead pilot whales on Snipe Point in the lower Keys about 6 miles north of Sugar Loaf Key. We believe these are part of the original pod of 51 stranded pilot whales. A rescue team is in route”.(source)

Whales were riding the tide. When the Gulf emptied they were left on the shelf.

Whales were riding the tide. When the Gulf emptied they were left on the shelf. By NOAA

NOAA ,scientists and ocean activists believe the whales that stranded on Snipe Point, north of Sugarloaf Key are part of the original 51 whales that stranded at Highland Point.

Whales trapped on ocean shelf by low tide.

Whales trapped on ocean shelf by low tide.

Barbara Napoles, experienced ocean navigator, and Floridian,explained it simply: “The current carried the whales to Snipe point, the Gulf is like a bowl that empties it’s contents into the Atlantic at low tide”.

It could be speculated that the whales were unable to navigate due to acoustic damage. They were simply carried by the current and as the Gulf emptied the whales were stranded on the shallow shelf between the keys.

Activists are wondering why NOAA/NMFS seems unaware of the Naval exercise taking place in the Atlantic Training Complex especially considering  there is an OPAREA  A danger zone is a defined water area used for target practice, bombing, rocket firing or other especially hazardous military activities, (a restricted air space used for Naval Exercises and Training) in the Florida Keys:” Via NOAAthe team is waiting to hear from the Navy.”(source)

The “Spartans” of NAS Jacksonville-based Helicopter Maritime Strike Squadron (HSM) 70 operate the MH-60R anti-submarine Seahawk helicopter from onboard the Bush and her accompanying ships”.(source) The MH60R helicopter used during the Bush Strike Group Comptuex training exercises is fully loaded, a deadly weapon that has the ability to kill, harm, “take” whales and dolphins. The MH60R is indeed equipped with an impressive array of defensive and counter defensive weaponry:

  • Sonobuoy launcher
  • Raytheon AN/AQS-22 advanced airborne low-frequency (ALFS) dipping sonar.
  • Lockheed Martin AGM-114 Hellfire anti-surface missiles.
  • The MH-60R can carry up to three ATK mk50 or mk46 active / passive lightweight torpedoes.
  •  7.62mm machine gun
  • Lockheed Martin AN/ALQ-210 electronic support measures system (ESM)
  • Electronic warfare systems include the ATK AN/AAR-47 missile warner,
  • Laser warning system
  • BAE Systems AN/ALQ-144 infrared jammer and
  • AN/ALE-39 chaff and flare decoy dispenser.
  • Raytheon AN/AAS-44 detecting / tracking system
  • Forward-looking infrared (FLIR) and laser rangefinder.
  • Telephonics AN/APS-147 multimode radar, which has inverse synthetic aperture (ISAR) imaging and periscope and small target detection capabilities.
  •  AN/APS-153 radar, with the automatic radar periscope detection and discrimination (ARPDD) capability.

“Scientists will arrive Monday to take samples of these 11 whales to determine cause of death. They are hoping to get better samples to investigate possible disease or biotoxin (e.g., red tide) causes. While there is no evidence to suggest sonar trauma, the team is waiting to hear from the Navy”.(Source)

NOAA/NMFS decision to wait until Monday to even begin the necropsy process on these whales is in itself negligent. The bodies of the whales will  have been decomposing for at least 18 hours and exposed to the elements. In addition, their denial that the whales showed signs related to acoustic trauma ie, disorientation, and inability to navigate as discussed in this article: Underwater sonar systems really DO cause whales to become stranded – because the high frequencies disorientate themseems they are trying to cast the blame away from the Navy and the cetacean victims of their friendly fire.

Short finned pilot whale

Short finned pilot whale by Pablo Gil

While Naval readiness is important when do we begin to question the clear cutting of our oceans by the ever increasing Naval exercises taking place in the waters off our shores. It’s time to clean up our own back yard and question the activities of the Navy and NOAA/NMFS who have rubber stamped their activities.

Update 12/9/2013

We understand that NOAA and the Navy cannot reveal or acknowledge COMPTUEX Naval Exercises because of National Security as was the case with the Cape Cod Strandings. We will be updating as necropsy results become available that we will begin trying to obtain via: the Freedom of Information Act. We encourage all activists to follow up as well.

Follow the NOAA updates on the pilot whales : Here

USGS Woods Hole is Requesting a Permit For Deadly Seismic Testing in The Gulf of Mexico

By Kirsten Massebeau

Stranded whale during seismic testing by Stephen Hambrick

Stranded Whale Photo By Nic Slocum

USGS Woods Hole has requested a permit from the National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration/National Marine Fisheries Service (NOAA/NMFS) to incidentally “take” marine mammals while conducting seismic testing in the Gulf of Mexico (GOM) in search of natural gas for future harvesting. The area is densely populated with whales, dolphins and other species of sea life. Woods Hole states:

“Numerous species of marine mammals inhabit the GOM. Several of these species are listed as endangered under the U.S. Endangered Species Act (ESA): the sperm, North Atlantic right, humpback, sei, fin, and blue whales, and the West Indian manatee. Other ESA-listed species that could occur in the area are the endangered leatherback, hawksbill, green, and Kemp’s ridley turtles, and the threatened loggerhead turtle”. (Source, Page 1)

Numbers of requested cetacean “Takes” by level B harassment of marine mammals:

  • Odontoceti 
  • Sperm whale: 3
  • Kogia spp. (Pygmy and dwarf sperm whale) 2.1 1 0.62 (0.31)—Pygmy sperm whale 0.44 (0.22)—Dwarf sperm whale 2
  • Small (Mesoplodon and Cuvier’s) beaked whale 3.7 2 3.51 (3.51)—Mesoplodon beaked whale 3.1 (3.1)—Cuvier’s beaked whale 2
  • Killer whale 0.40 0 0 0
  • Short-finned pilot whale 6.3 3 2.65 (0.42) 19
  • False killer whale 2.7 1 4.63 (0.13) 36
  • Melon-headed whale 9.1 4 5.17 (0.18) 118
  • Pygmy killer whale 1.1 0 0 0
  • Risso’s dolphin 10.0 4 0.57 (0.25) 9
  • Bottlenose dolphin 32 
  • Bottlenose dolphin Northern GOM oceanic stock 18
  • Rough-toothed dolphin 6.7 3 0.6 (0.11) 16
  • Fraser’s dolphin 1.9 1 NA (NA) 117
  • Striped dolphin 51.5 23 1.35 (0.69) 45
  • Pantropical spotted dolphin 582.6 259 0.76 (0.76) 259
  • Atlantic spotted dolphin 2.2 1 NA (NA) 15
  • Spinner dolphin 72.6 32 4.98 (1.61) 99
  • Clymene dolphin 45.6 20 1.14 (0.3) 75 (Source Page 16)

Note: There is no way that Woods Hole can guarantee there will be no incidents of injury and mortality.

Seismic Survey

Diagram of a Seismic Survey

The claim that seismic testing does not cause harm provided by Woods Hole is weak and outdated:

“The effects of sounds from air guns could include one or more of the following: tolerance, masking of natural sounds, behavioral disturbance, and at least in theory, temporary or permanent hearing impairment, or non-auditory physical or physiological effects (Richardson et al. 1995; Gordon et al. 2004; Nowacek et al. 2007; Southall et al. 2007). Permanent hearing impairment, in the unlikely event that it occurred, would constitute injury, but temporary threshold shift (TTS) is not an injury (Southall et al. 2007). Although the possibility cannot be entirely excluded, it is unlikely that the project would result in any cases of temporary or permanent hearing impairment, or any significant non-auditory physical or physiological effects. If marine mammals encounter the survey while it is underway, some behavioral disturbance could result, but this would be localized and short-term. As a result of the monitoring and mitigation measures, no marine mammals are expected to be exposed to sounds from the survey at levels causing behavioral disturbance”. (Source Page 16)

Although Woods Hole states the airguns will emit decibels between 160 and 190 dB the air guns are capable of reaching 230dB and can cause hearing damage,bleeding of the brain,behavioral issues,and strandings. The proposed permit would allow Woods Hole to run air guns in the two survey areas non stop for 96 hours at each location.  When a survey was suspended in 2012 in the same area Michael Jasny of Natural Resources Defense Council had this to say: “Imagine dynamite going off in your neighborhood for days, months on end,” said Michael Jasny, a senior policy analyst at the NRDC. That’s the situation these animals are facing.”(Source) Marine mammals depend on their sensitive hearing for survival. Hearing loss for a cetacean can mean inability to function, hunt, navigate and cause death.

By Ocean Conservation Research

By Ocean Conservation Research

Listen the underwater explosion created by an airgun. See the explosion created by just one air-gun.

Blue Voice was on the scene as 2800 dolphins continued to wash up on the beaches of North Peru

Blue Voice was on the scene as 2800 dolphins continued to wash up on the beaches of North Peru.

Everyday more instances of injury and death due to seismic testing are being documented. While almost all oil and gas exploration companies deny harm to marine life can be caused by seismic testing non profit organizations and ocean advocates are compiling proof that in-fact seismic testing is deadly to marine life as can be seen in Peru in April of 2012 where 2800 dolphins washed ashore. Hardy Jones of Blue Voice.org working with Veterinarian Carlos Yaipén’s released these test results taken from viable dolphin tissue samples:

“We found that stranded dolphins had the following signs: a. Bleeding in the middle ear. b. Simple fracture and cracks in the middle ear (periodic) bones.c. Hemorrhage and bubbles in mandibular fat (where dolphins perceive incoming sounds) d. Massive invasion of air bubbles which displaced the normal tissue of vital organs such as lungs, liver, kidney, bladder and blood vessels.e. Pulmonary emphysema: air bubbles, bleeding and massive destruction of lung tissue” (Source) All of these symptoms concur with the effects of seismic testing on cetaceans: “What he has found is evidence of acoustical trauma leading to rapid ascent and decompression syndrome. In other words loud noises, produced repeatedly over a long period of time, startled the dolphins who raced for the surface and incurred what humans call the bends”.(Source)

The sperm whale is just one of the species that will be exposed to seismic sound

The sperm whale is just one of the species that will be exposed to 190-230 dB of explosive sound.

Be a voice for whales and dolphins:  Send your comments objecting to the issuance of a permit, and requesting a public hearing be held before the Marine Mammal Commission. Air guns producing 190 dB blasts underwater, for 96 hours at a time in areas densely populated with sea life is unacceptable. Let them know that their form of monitoring, “look outs” (people looking for marine mammals from the deck of the ship during the survey) is unacceptable as they can only see the surface of the ocean and: 1) while the air gun explosions will be as deep as 2000 meters. 2) Whales and dolphins spend most of their lives underwater

Include the Document Citation: 78 FR 11821

Include the Document Number:2013-03837

You must submit your comments and objections to:


You can also send written letters of objection to: P. Michael PayneChief, permits and conservation division, office of protected resources, NMFS,1315 East -West Highway,Silver Spring ,Maryland 20910.  

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Howard Goldstein or Jolie Harrison, Office of Protected Resources, NMFS, 301-427-8401.

Join the Facebook event:

“Deny US Geological Survey NOAA permit for the “Taking”of Marine Mammals”